Episode 1
Aired Apr 9, 2023
A Man With a Past
Lori Ann Slesinski vanished in 2006, and police believed the prime suspect, her friend Rick Ennis, was the last to see her alive, and he killed his parents when he was 12.
Details
Episode 2
Aired Apr 16, 2023
The COVID Cover-Up: Searching for Gretchen Anthony
When Gretchen Anthony's friends and family began receiving texts saying she had coronavirus, they grew worried; then the messages stopped; Peter Van Sant reports.
Details
Episode 3
Aired Apr 26, 2023
The Kidnapping of Schanda Handley
Kidnapped at gunpoint, Schanda Handley knew exactly who was behind it -- her ex-husband, Michael Handley; a tumultuous relationship riddled with threats and assaults turned even more hostile the day Schanda was convinced she would die.
Details
Episode 4
Aired May 8, 2023
The Snapchat Clue
After married couple Krista and Bart Halderson suddenly disappears, clues on the social media app Snapchat point to a culprit that no one would ever suspect.
Details
Episode 5
Aired May 15, 2023
The Unsolvable Murder of Roxanne Wood
In 1987, Terry Wood comes home to find his wife, Roxanne Wood, dead; investigators preserve DNA, but technological limitations of the time turn the case cold, until now.
Details
Episode 6
Aired May 22, 2023
Last Seen in Breckenridge
Detectives link the 1982 murders of two women near Breckenridge, Colo., through matching orange socks, but the case goes cold for decades until investigators turn to genealogy for clues.
Details
Episode 7
Aired May 29, 2023
The Case Against Michael Politte
In 1998, police charge 14-year-old Michael Politte with the murder of his mother, Rita, after she was hit on the head and set on fire in her Missouri home; a jury sentences him to life without parole until a law passes that may give him a chance.
Details
Episode 8
Aired Jun 5, 2023
The Strange Death of Professor Shockley
A night of music and hot-tubbing leads to professor Marianne Shockley's death and former psychologist Clark Heindel killing himself; police charge Shockley's boyfriend, Marcus Lillard, with her death.
Details
Episode 9
Aired Jun 12, 2023
The Tree That Helped Solve a Murder
Joseph Elledge reports his wife Mengqi Ji missing; they uncover her remains buried under a juniper tree; police try to use DNA found on that tree to catch her killer.
Details
Episode 10
Aired Jun 19, 2023
The Shooting of Lauren Kanarek
Olympic equestrian-turned-trainer Michael Barisone claims temporary insanity when police charge him with the attempted murder of Lauren Kanarek, a student he shot twice in the chest after she tried to ruin his reputation online.
Details
Episode 11
Aired Jul 10, 2023
Death Hits Home: The Hargan Killings
Millionaire mother Pam Hargan and her adult daughter, Helen, are found murdered in their northern Virginia home; the police tell the family her wound looks self-inflicted.
Details
Episode 12
Aired Aug 20, 2023
Melissa Turner's Closing Act
Melissa Turner of Florida called 911, saying she had discovered her fiancé, Matthew Trussler, lying unresponsive near their swimming pool; he was pronounced dead at the scene in October 2019, but an autopsy later revealed he died from stab wounds.
Details
Episode 13
Aired Aug 27, 2023
Convinced To Kill?
Peter Van Sant examines the final chapter in the case against Jacob Nolan, who claims his cousin and psychiatrist, Dr. Pamela Buchbinder, brainwashed him into attempting to kill her ex-over, Dr. Michael Weiss, while in a custody battle for their son.
Details
Episode 14
Aired Sep 3, 2023
The Daughters Who Disappeared
In 1997, four families from Texas and Oklahoma are crushed when their daughters go missing, and the cases go cold; decades later, the serial killer himself helps investigators solve those murders.
Details
Episode 15
Aired Sep 17, 2023
The Idaho Student Murders
Criminology Ph.D. student Bryan Kohberger is charged with the murder of four University of Idaho students.
Details
Episode 16
Aired Sep 10, 2023
The Kidnapping of Michelle and Breea Renee
Three masked gunmen broke into bank manager Michelle Renee's California home in November 2000 and forced her to rob her own bank to save her daughter Breea's life. Then, her abductor falsely claimed Michelle was in on the crime.
Details
Episode 17
Aired Oct 1, 2023
Alisa Mathewson's Night Terrors
Alisa Mathewson suffered a 55-hour ordeal that almost cost her life at the hands of her estranged husband, Trevor Summers; she shares her harrowing experience of being kidnapped and sexually assaulted with Peter Van Sant.
Details
Episode 18
Aired Oct 8, 2023
Kassanndra's Secret
Three days after Kassanndra Cantrell's 2020 disappearance, police discover eerie surveillance footage of her attacker and soon realize the two were linked by a secret.
Details
Episode 19
Aired Oct 15, 2023
What Angelina Saw
Angelina Fernandes, 11 years old at the time, witnesses her mother in distress at a bloody crime scene; she claimed she acted in self-defense when she fatally stabbed her fiancé, Andy Wagner, but it would be up to a jury to decide what happened.
Details
Episode 20
Aired Oct 22, 2023
A Stabbing in Colts Neck
Donna Ongsiako was alone in her New Jersey home when she heard a noise downstairs; she thought she forgot to let the cat in, so she opened the door; there, she suffered a horrific knife attack by an unusual suspect; Jim Axelrod reports.
Details
Episode 21
Aired Oct 29, 2023
The Mysterious Death of Tiffiney Crawford
Tiffiney Crawford, a wife and mother, is found dead in her van with two bullet wounds to her head and a gun in her hand; investigators' first impression is that she killed herself, but they soon realize it might be a murder.
Details
Episode 22
Aired Oct 11, 2023
The Brighton Ax Murder
On Feb. 19, 1982, Jim Krauseneck tells police he found his wife, Cathy, dead in their bed with an ax in her head; for four decades, Cathy's murder remained unsolved until now.
Details
Episode 23
Aired Oct 18, 2023
Lori Vallow Daybell: Guilty
In May 2023, an Idaho jury finds Lori Vallow Daybell guilty of murdering her two children, JJ Vallow and Tylee Ryan, and conspiring in the murder of her husband Chad Daybell's ex-wife, Tammy; Jonathan Vigliotti reports.
Details
Episode 24
Aired Nov 1, 2023
Where is Diana Duve?
Diana Duve was last seen alive leaving a bar in Vero Beach, Fla., with her on-again, off-again boyfriend, Mike Jones; her mother knew something was wrong when Diana didn't call her, something she did every day.
Details
Episode 25
Aired Oct 25, 2023
Christy and Hilda's Last Dance
A night out for two friends in Los Angeles ends in tragedy after masked men drop them off at separate hospitals; the young women die from drug overdoses, and police immediately suspect foul play; Jonathan Vigliotti investigates.
Details
Episode 26
Aired Nov 8, 2023
The Night of the Idaho Student Murders
Criminology Ph.D. student Bryan Kohberger is charged with the murder of four University of Idaho students; in November 2022, Kaylee Goncalves, Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle and Madison Mogen are found dead in their home; Peter Van Sant reports.
Details
Episode 27
Aired Jan 7, 2024
Remembering the Chowchilla Kidnapping
In August 2022, after 46 years, the last of three men convicted of kidnapping 26 children and their bus driver was paroled from a prison in California; survivors of that harrowing event share powerful and emotional interviews with David Begnaud.
Details
Episode 28
Aired Feb 4, 2024
The Case of the Poison Cheesecake
A beauty stylist is almost murdered in 2016 by a client who comes to her home and poisons her with a piece of cheesecake; the motive doesn't make sense to police until they realize that the stylist and the client have an uncanny physical resemblance.
Details