Big Ed Self Colt Johnson Self Norma Brown Self Vanessa Guerra Self Syngin Colchester Self Debbie Johnson Self Liz Marie Self Jeniffer Tarazona Self Tania Maduro Self Jesse Meester Self Tim Malcolm Contestant Stephanie Matto Contestant Natalie Podiakova Contestant Shaun Robinson Host Julianne Klein Producer Michael Twigg Creative Producer James H. Fitzgerald Assistant Director