Justin Spitzer Creator, Executive Producer Ana Gasteyer Katherine Actor Jon Barinholtz Wesley Actor Harriet Dyer Sadie Actor Humphrey Ker Elliot Actor Michael Benjamin Washington Cyrus Actor Tye White Jack Actor X Mayo Dori Actor Andrew Daly Frank Guest Star Alexandra Siegel Michelle Guest Star Matthew Owen Murray Bennett Guest Star Ian McQuown AJ Guest Star Provvidenza Catalano Recast Actress Guest Star Brent Pope Crew Member 1 Guest Star Atticus Batacan First AD Guest Star Henita Telo Costumer Guest Star Jordan Birkland Tamara Guest Star Daisy Washington Teenage Girl Guest Star Anthony Skeen Crew Member 2 Guest Star Jeffrey Blitz Executive Producer, Director Aaron Kaplan Executive Producer Dana Honor Executive Producer Albertina Rizzo Writer