American Horror Story: Roanoke Episode 3 - TV Reviews - Rotten Tomatoes

American Horror Story: Roanoke Episode 3 Reviews

Page 1 of 1
Emma Dibdin
Harper's Bazaar
September 29, 2017

This third episode was by far the most outlandishly nuts yet.

Brian Acunis
The Young Folks
October 3, 2016

Right now, my reason for viewing are the performances from Paulson, Gooding Jr., and Bassett.

Full Review | Original Score: 7.5/10
Mark Trammell
TV Equals
September 29, 2016

I must admit, this has been fun, trying to figure out where all this is going, and if the idea was to keep people guessing and engaged, then in that case, Murphy and company have already succeeded.

Clarisse Loughrey
Independent (UK)
Top Critic
September 29, 2016

[It] provides a perfect dramatic cliffhanger to leave us on; like we've reached the peak of a rollercoaster, waiting now for the inevitable descent.

Elizabeth Rayne
Den of Geek
September 29, 2016

American Horror Story has redeemed itself in the bloodiest, goriest, most knife-throwing, throat-slitting, flesh-burning, cannibalistic way.

Jonathan Bernstein
Daily Telegraph (UK)
Top Critic
September 29, 2016

There's the introduction of a new character who compensates for the camp humor missing from the series up to now, and we finally get a partial explanation for the spooky goings on in the woods.

Emily L. Stephens
AV Club
Top Critic
September 29, 2016

In "Chapter 3" of American Horror Story: Roanoke, Kathy Bates is here to kick ass and eat still-beating hearts. And she's all out of hearts.

Full Review | Original Score: B-
Joanna Robinson
Vanity Fair
September 29, 2016

Three episodes into American Horror Story and a clear pattern of callbacks is starting to emerge. FX and its marketing may be calling this the Roanoke season, but I'm inclined to call it American Horror Story: Meta.

Alexander Zalben
September 29, 2016

Needless to say, things are getting real complicated, real quick... And they didn't calm down at all this episode.

Jeff Stone
Top Critic
September 29, 2016

Chapter 3 is a very busy episode, yet it still manages to be completely dull, which is sad to say about an episode that features feral children, hypnotism sex, and outrageous old-timey (Irish?) accents.

Full Review | Original Score: C-
Caralynn Lippo
TV Fanatic
September 29, 2016

This was the best installment of the season yet.

Full Review | Original Score: 4.5/5
Matt Fowler
IGN Movies
September 28, 2016

Despite still lacking in the chills department, Roanoke gave us much more than a haunted house story this week.

Full Review | Original Score: 7.3/10
Marc Snetiker
Entertainment Weekly
Top Critic
September 28, 2016

American Horror Story: Pig Year returns in its third week with, finally, some explanation of the colonial mythos that's been haunting the Roanoke farmhouse where Shelby, Matt, and Lee have been terrorized.

Page 1 of 1