Tom Segura Various Characters Creator, Actor Luke Wilson Mark Actor Tim Baltz Simon Actor Busy Philipps Suzanne Actor Kate Simses Alyssa Actor Mike Mitchell Teddy Actor Amber Dancy Rhonda (Agent #1), Yoshi Mashimoto, Aiko Guest Star, Guest Star, Guest Star, Actor, Director Alex English Edgar (Agent #2) Guest Star, Writer Ryan Sickler Tracy (Agent #3) Guest Star Douglas Olsson Presenter Guest Star Dominique Washington Tess the Assistant Guest Star Robert Iler Actor Daniella Pineda Actor Nic Novicki Actor Johnny Pemberton Actor Rachel Bloom Actor Kirk Fox Actor Christina Pazsitzky Actor Kevin Nealon Actor Floriana Lima Actor Helen Hong Actor Jamie-Lynn Sigler Actor Maria Bamford Actor Odette Annable Actor Martha Kelly Actor Allegra Edwards Actor Jeremy Konner Director Ryan Hall Executive Producer Tyler Cornack Director Conor Galvin Writer Greg Garcia Writer Jordan Jensen Writer Nicholas Wiesnet Cinematographer Waldemar Centeno Film Editor Jeremy Cohen Film Editor Marissa Mueller Film Editor Melissa DeLizia Casting