Joe Barber II Contestant Dustin Erikstrup Contestant Dani Briones Contestant Dick Donato Contestant Jessica Hughbanks Contestant Carol Journey Contestant Jameka Cameron Contestant Amber Siyavus Contestant Mike Dutz Contestant Nick Starcevic Contestant Kail Harbick Contestant Eric Stein Contestant Jen Johnson Contestant Zach Swerdzewski Contestant Julie Chen Host Arnold Shapiro Executive Producer Allison Grodner Executive Producer