James Spader Alan Shore Actor John Larroquette Carl Sack Actor Christian Clemenson Jerry Espenson Actor Tara Summers Katie Lloyd Actor Candice Bergen Shirley Schmidt Actor William Shatner Denny Crane Actor Rene Auberjonois Paul Lewiston Guest Star Roma Maffia Judge Victoria Peyton Guest Star Ming Lo Hyung Lee Guest Star Jack Shearer Justice Antonin Scalia Guest Star John Posey Chief Justice Roberts Guest Star Raymond Ma Zhu Chang Guest Star Vito D'Ambrosio Justice Samuel Alito Guest Star Jim Turner Father Joseph Martin Guest Star Marianne Muellerleile Evelyn Guest Star David E. Kelley Executive Producer, Writer Bill D'Elia Executive Producer Susan Dickes Writer