Mary Elizabeth Winstead Laurel Healy Actor Danny Pino Luke Healy Actor Aaron Tveit Gareth Ritter Actor Tony Shalhoub Red Wheatus Actor Nikki M. James Rochelle Daudier Actor Johnny Ray Gill Gustav Triplett Actor Jan Maxwell Ella Pollack Actor Charlie Semine Anthony Onofrio Actor Paige Patterson Guest Star Zach Grenier Guest Star Helen Carey Guest Star Beth Malone Guest Star Brooke Adams Guest Star Mia Dillon Guest Star Dakin Matthews Guest Star Tom Kemp Guest Star Jonathan Coulton Guest Star Yaegel T. Welch Guest Star Patrick Breen Guest Star Peter Rini Guest Star Slate Holmgren Guest Star Gabriella Pizzolo Guest Star Sean Patrick Folster Guest Star Kenneth Tigar Guest Star James Lloyd Reynolds Guest Star Spencer House Guest Star Robert King Executive Producer, Director Michelle King Executive Producer Ridley Scott Executive Producer David W. Zucker Executive Producer Brooke Kennedy Executive Producer Liz Glotzer Executive Producer Jacquelyn Reingold Writer Jonathan Tolins Writer