Italia Ricci April Carver Actor Mary Page Keller Sara Carver Actor Aisha Dee Beth Kingston Actor Richard Brancatisano Dominic Actor Haley Ramm Brenna Carver Actor Scott Michael Foster Leo Hendrie Actor Rebecca Schull Emma Guest Star Merrin Dungey Dr. Susan Hamburg Guest Star Abhi Sinha Danny Gupta Guest Star Jessica Meraz Natalie Ortiz Guest Star Krysta Rodriguez Vanessa Guest Star Dylan Gelula Ford Guest Star Aurora Perrineau Margo Guest Star Alycia Grant Meg Guest Star Ross Butler Hunter Guest Star Anthony Garland Mark Guest Star Edward Hendershott Jesse Guest Star Patrick Sean Smith Executive Producer Susanna Fogel Executive Producer, Writer Joni Lefkowitz Executive Producer Aaron Kaplan Executive Producer Charlie Stratton Director