Aline Brosh McKenna Creator, Executive Producer Rachel Bloom Rebecca Bunch Creator, Actor, Executive Producer Vincent Rodriguez III Josh Chan Actor Santino Fontana Greg Serrano Actor Donna Lynne Champlin Paula Proctor Actor Vella Lovell Heather Patel Actor Pete Gardner Darryl Whitefeather Actor Gabrielle Ruiz Valencia Perez Actor Jayden Lund Guardrail Guest Star Marc Webb Executive Producer Erin Ehrlich Executive Producer Rene Gube Writer Jay Chandrasekhar Director