Forest Whitaker Special Agent Sam Cooper Actor Janeane Garofalo Beth Griffith Actor Michael Kelly John "Prophet" Sims Actor Beau Garrett Gina LaSalle Actor Matt Ryan Mick Rawson Actor Kirsten Vangsness Penelope Garcia Actor Noel Fisher Jason Wheeler Guest Star Michelle Bonilla Det. Nina Hernandez Guest Star Jessica Tuck Amy Wheeler Guest Star Michelle Burke Carol Langstrom Guest Star Tony Cicchetti Businessman (Carl Langstrom) Guest Star Darius Dudley Memorial Speaker Guest Star Víctor López Morgue Worker Guest Star Eileen Fogarty Woman Guest Star Franklin Dennis Jones Man Guest Star Stephanie Ortiz Delivery Girl Guest Star Jake Mervine Architect (Running Man) Guest Star Nina Nayebi Vendor's Wife Guest Star Rochelle Hogue Businesswoman Guest Star Chris Mundy Executive Producer Edward Allen Bernero Executive Producer Mark Gordon Executive Producer Deborah Spera Executive Producer Terry McDonough Director Rob Fresco Writer