Ashley Undercuffler Alisha Sidie Actor Donald Buie Self Marken Greenwood Jenelle Actor Kelvin Taylor Brian Golsby Actor Kahlo De Jesus Buffington Self Danny McFarland Deputy Joe Actor Frank Edward Jesse Actor Paul Lilley Doug Actor Diana Caban Velez Kathy Actor James Patrick Duffy Self Bob Keppel Self William Guirola Juan Guest Star Nancy Harding Stoney's Sister Guest Star Tyler Hayse John , Tony Guest Star Elena Kornilova Friend of the victim Actor Frank Atchley Self India Everett Victim's Friend Guest Star Bob Lamoria Self Jose Malvar Jr. Self Keegan Guy Jarod Guest Star Adam Kassen Director, Executive Producer Dick Wolf Executive Producer Tom Thayer Executive Producer Pam Healey Executive Producer John Hesling Executive Producer Kourtney Gleason Producer Colin Sherman Producer