Joe Mantegna David Rossi Actor, Director Matthew Gray Gubler Dr. Spencer Reid Actor Kirsten Vangsness Penelope Garcia Actor A.J. Cook Jennifer Jareau Actor Adam Rodriguez Luke Alvez Actor Aisha Tyler Dr. Tara Lewis Actor Paget Brewster Emily Prentiss Actor Damon Gupton Stephen Walker Actor Blake Webb Ben Davis Guest Star Murphy Cross Virginia Davis Guest Star Robert Torti Sheriff Scott Paseo Guest Star Robert Miano Prospector Guest Star Minerva García M.E. Elizabeth Padilla Guest Star Jacob Loeb Joey Fletcher Guest Star Nikki Crawford Marla Grace Guest Star Alfred Adderly Malcolm Guest Star Ani Sava Rosa Medina Guest Star Travis Greer Guard Butler, Guard 3 Guest Star Bodhi Elfman Peter Lewis Guest Star Mark Gordon Executive Producer Erica Messer Executive Producer Breen Frazier Executive Producer Bruce Zimmerman Writer