Joshua Jackson Max Bankman Actor Don Johnson Captain Robert Massey Actor Phillipa Soo Avery Morgan Actor Sean Teale Tristan Silva Actor Gina Gershon Lenore Laurent Actor Justin Jedlica Ken Actor Constance Marie Caroline Von Dreesen Actor Hayley McLaughlin Jessa Actor Mikayla Soo-ni Campbell Pippa Actor Blanca Araceli Viva Actor Amanda Rea Barbie Actor Jacob Dacus Allan Actor Bradley Buecker Director Ryan Murphy Writer, Executive Producer Jon Robin Baitz Writer Joe Baken Writer Julia Newman Original Music