Ashley Benson Mia Torcoletti Actor Jon Bernthal Raymond Gardener Actor Veronica Cartwright Bun Waverly Actor Jaime Ray Newman Kat Gardener Actor Lindsay Price Joanna Frankel Actor Rebecca Romijn Roxanne (Roxie) Tercoletti Actor Sara Rue Penny Actor Johann Urb Will Actor Paul Gross Darryl Van Horne Actor Matt Dallas Guest Star Cybill Shepherd Guest Star Jack Huston Guest Star Jason George Guest Star Torsten Voges Guest Star Darren Criss Guest Star Nynno Ahli Guest Star Steve Hytner Guest Star Mia Hays Guest Star Emily Alyn Lind Guest Star John Paul Foster Guest Star Maggie Friedman Executive Producer, Writer David S. Rosenthal Executive Producer, Writer Rina Mimoun Writer Nancy Won Writer Annie Weisman Writer Chris Dingess Writer Fred Gerber Director Wendy Mericle Writer Michael Katleman Director Elodie Keene Director John Terlesky Director Wendey Stanzler Director Bill D'Elia Director Kevin Rodney Sullivan Director Tom Verica Director David Nutter Director Dan Lerner Director