Allison Tolman Jo Evans Actor Alexa Swinton Piper Actor Owain Yeoman Benny Gallagher Actor Ashley Aufderheide Mia Evans Actor Robert Bailey Jr. Officer Chris Minetto Actor Zabryna Guevara Abby Frasier Actor Donald Faison Alex Evans Actor Clancy Brown Ed Sawyer Actor Maria Dizzia Emily Guest Star Seth Barrish Alan Wilkis Guest Star Dana Wheeler-Nicholson Vanessa Cox Guest Star Rowena King Helen Guest Star Enver Gjokaj Agent Ryan Brooks Guest Star Michele Fazekas Executive Producer Tara Butters Executive Producer Paul McGuigan Executive Producer Lindsey Allen Writer Jessica Lowrey Director