Katja Herbers Kristen Bouchard Actor Mike Colter David Acosta Actor Aasif Mandvi Ben Shakir Actor Michael Emerson Leland Townsend Actor Christine Lahti Sheryl Luria Actor Kurt Fuller Dr. Boggs Actor Brooklyn Shuck Lynn Bouchard Actor Skylar Gray Lila Bouchard Actor Maddy Crocco Lexis Bouchard Actor Dalya Knapp Laura Bouchard Actor Peter Scolari Bishop Thomas Marx Guest Star Patrick Brammall Andy Bouchard Guest Star Renée Elise Goldsberry Renee Harris Guest Star Taylor Louderman Malindaz Guest Star James Udom Father Walsh Guest Star Alison Cimmet Sister Elena Guest Star Sophia Anne Caruso Emma Guest Star Julia Nightingale Olivia Guest Star Q. Smith Choir Director Guest Star Jonathan Coulton Jonathan Coulton Guest Star Kara Oates Choir Member Guest Star Eve O'Brien Choir Member Guest Star Sadie Seelert Choir Member Guest Star Samantha Blaire Cutler Erin Guest Star Sarah-Anne Martinez Mia Guest Star Jasmine Rogers Charlotte Guest Star Sondrine Lee Bontemps Choir Member Guest Star Alex Colavecchio Choir Member Guest Star Korina Lea Deming Choir Member Guest Star Julia Hemp Choir Member Guest Star Ileena Irving Choir Member Guest Star Alexa Magro Choir Member Guest Star Grace Martini Choir Member Guest Star Megumi Nakamura Choir Member Guest Star Brianna Lena Oristano Choir Member Guest Star Leon Pintel Choir Member Guest Star Kiaya Scott Choir Member Guest Star Jada Temple Choir Member Guest Star Keaton Whittaker Choir Member Guest Star Georgi James Gigi Guest Star Laila Drew Girl 1 in Cafeteria Guest Star Alexa Shae Niziak Girl 2 in Cafeteria Guest Star Michelle King Executive Producer Robert King Executive Producer Liz Glotzer Executive Producer Rockne S. O'Bannon Writer John Dahl Director