Paul DiMeo Self Paige Hemmis Self Michael Moloney Self Constance Ramos Self Ed Sanders Self Preston Sharp Self Eduardo Xol Self Tanya McQueen Self Mandy Moore Guest Star Daniel Kucan Self Tracy Hutson Self John Littlefield Self Marlee Matlin Guest Star Trace Adkins Guest Star Ty Pennington Host Tim McGraw Guest Star Tom Forman Executive Producer Denise Cramsey Executive Producer Juan Cruz Bucich Director Patrick Higgins Director Jack Cannon Director