McKenzie Westmore Host Ve Neill Judge Glenn Hetrick Judge Patrick Tatopoulos Judge Athena Zhe Contestant Beki Ingram Contestant Brea Joseph Contestant Gerald "Jerry" Macaluso Contestant Greg Lightner Contestant Heather Henry Contestant Ian Cromer Contestant Matt Valentine Contestant Miranda Jory Contestant Nicholas "Nix" Herrera Contestant Rayce Bird Contestant Sue Lee Contestant Tara Lang Contestant Catherine O'Hara Guest LeVar Burton Guest Michael Agbabian Executive Producer Dwight D. Smith Executive Producer