McKenzie Westmore Host Glenn Hetrick Judge Neville Page Judge Ve Neill Judge Michael Westmore Self Anna Cali Contestant Anthony Canonica Jr. Contestant Greg Schrantz Contestant Jennifer Bowden Contestant Johnny Leftwich Contestant Kaleb Lewis Contestant Katie Kinney Contestant Mel Licata Contestant Melissa Ebbe Contestant Njoroge Karumba Contestant Rob Seal Contestant Robert Lindsay Contestant Walter Welsh Contestant Yvonne Cox Contestant Michael Agbabian Executive Producer Dwight D. Smith Executive Producer Derek Atherton Executive Producer