McKenzie Westmore Host Glenn Hetrick Judge Neville Page Judge Ve Neill Judge Michael Westmore Self Faina Rudshteyn Contestant Alan Tuskes Contestant Philip Harrah Contestant Suzanne Bostwick Contestant KC Mussman Contestant Laura McCormick Contestant Andrew Freeman Contestant Jill Burgner Contestant Kierstin LaPatka Contestant Nelson Cooper Contestant Joseph Drobezko Contestant Nicolas Fischer Contestant Michael Agbabian Executive Producer Dwight D. Smith Executive Producer Derek Atherton Executive Producer