Jemaine Clement Jemaine Actor, Writer, Executive Producer Bret McKenzie Bret Actor, Writer, Executive Producer Rhys Darby Murray Hewitt Actor Kristen Schaal Mel Actor Arj Barker Dave Actor Eugene Mirman Eugene Actor David Costabile Doug Actor Todd Barry Todd Guest Star Frank Wood Greg Actor Jon Budinoff Mexican Boy Guest Star June Diane Raphael Felicia Actor Sutton Foster Coco Guest Star Rachel Blanchard Sally Guest Star Sarah Burns Summer Guest Star Steve Sirkis Club Guy Guest Star Judah Friedlander Isabella Guest Star Eddie Pepitone Eddie Guest Star Dan Bakkedahl Waiter Guest Star Ramsey Faragallah John Guest Star Marilyn Torres Jemaine's Date Guest Star James Bobin Writer, Executive Producer, Director Troy Miller Executive Producer, Director Stu Smiley Executive Producer Tracey Baird Executive Producer Taika Waititi Director, Writer Michael Patrick Jann Director Paul Simms Director, Writer Duncan Sarkies Writer Damon Beesley Writer Iain Morris Writer