Annabel Oakes Creator, Executive Producer Marisa Davila Jane Actor Cheyenne Isabel Wells Olivia Actor Ari Notartomaso Cynthia Actor Tricia Fukuhara Nancy Actor Shanel Bailey Hazel Actor Madison Thompson Susan Actor Johnathan Nieves Richie Actor Jason Schmidt Buddy Actor Jackie Hoffman Asst. Principal McGee Actor Marty Bowen Executive Producer Erik Feig Executive Producer Alethea Jones Executive Producer, Producer Wyck Godfrey Executive Producer Adam Fishbach Executive Producer