Donal Logue Sean Finnerty Actor Megyn Price Claudia Finnerty Actor Kevin Corrigan Eddie Finnerty Actor Lynsey Bartilson Lily Finnerty Actor Griffin Frazen Jimmy Finnerty Actor Jake Burbage Henry Finnerty Actor Bret Harrison Brad O'Keefe Actor Miriam Flynn Sister Helen Guest Star Emmett Shoemaker Ryan Guest Star Sean Masterson Tom Guest Star Lisa Arch Rebecca Guest Star Jessica Stier Ashley Guest Star Di Quon Natalie Guest Star Daniel Farber Mitchell Guest Star Jarrett Lennon Croyce Guest Star Chancellor Miller Kid in the Crowd Guest Star Hira Ambrosino Mrs. Pollack Guest Star John Putch Director Ned Goldreyer Writer