Christopher Cantwell Creator Christopher C. Rogers Creator Lee Pace Actor Scoot McNairy Actor Mackenzie Davis Actor Kerry Bishé Actor Toby Huss Actor David Wilson Barnes Dale Butler Guest Star Graham Beckel Nathan Cardiff Guest Star Mike Pniewski Barry Shields Guest Star Lisa Sheridan Rebecca Taylor Guest Star Maggie Elizabeth Jones Joanie Clark Guest Star Morgan Hinkleman Joanie Clark Guest Star Lou Anne Cooper Maylene Guest Star Ed Amatrudo Professor Guest Star Barry Stoltze Executive 1 Guest Star Robert Larriviere Executive 2 Guest Star John Atwood Vice President of Development Guest Star John Michael Morris Disgruntled Arcade Customer Guest Star Jonathan Lisco Executive Producer Mark Johnson Executive Producer Melissa Bernstein Executive Producer