David Sutcliffe Patrick Owen Actor Teri Polo Alex Young Actor Danny Comden Stevie Hanson Actor Rhea Seehorn Cheri Baldzikowski Actor Brooke Shields Guest Star Anne Bellamy Guest Star John O'Leary Guest Star Fred Pinkard Guest Star Mark Ankeny Guest Star Chris Henchy Guest Star, Executive Producer, Writer Brian Unger Guest Star Keegan-Michael Key Guest Star Jeanette Miller Guest Star Marco Pennette Executive Producer, Writer Michael Tollin Executive Producer Brian Robbins Executive Producer Joe Davola Executive Producer Shelley Jensen Director