Inbar Lavi Maddie Actor Rob Heaps Ezra Actor Parker Young Richard Actor Stephen Bishop Patrick Actor Marianne Rendón Jules Actor Brian Benben Max Actor Katherine LaNasa Sally Actor Taylor Handley Fluke Guest Star Maya Kazan Deputy Kim Bullock Guest Star Sam Gilroy Michael Guest Star Paul Adelstein Shelly Cohen Guest Star, Executive Producer Shawn Devlin Portly Man Guest Star Shant Srabian Landlord Guest Star Jason Jazrawy Agent Paul Mangrove Guest Star Elizabeth Saunders Mrs. G Guest Star Nicolas Grimes Mammoth Guy Guest Star Adam Brooks Executive Producer