Dave Navarro Host Chris Nunez Judge Oliver Peck Judge Christian Buckingham Contestant Corey Davis Contestant Miami Burgess Contestant Picasso Dular Contestant Cris Gherman Contestant Anthony Michaels Contestant Megan Jean Morris Contestant Alex Rockoff Contestant Ashley Velazquez Contestant Matti Hixson Contestant Jime Litwalk Contestant Walter "Sausage" Frank Contestant St. Marq Contestant Sarah Miller Contestant Cleen Rock One Contestant Jesse Smith Contestant James Vaughn Contestant Charlie Corwin Executive Producer Andrea Richter Executive Producer