Dave Navarro Host Chris Nunez Judge Oliver Peck Judge Eva Huber Contestant April Nicole Contestant Dane Smith Contestant Carlos Rojas Contestant Aric Taylor Contestant Thom Bulman Contestant Derek Zielinski Contestant Jessy Knuckles Contestant Allisin Riot Contestant Wes Hogan Contestant Mike Petroskie Contestant Jhon Campuzano Contestant Babiery Hernandez Contestant Chavonna "Bang" Rhodes Contestant "Danger" Dave Morris Contestant Erin Chance Contestant Doom Kitten Contestant Andrea Richter Executive Producer Steven Weinstock Executive Producer Glenda Hersh Executive Producer