Reid Scott Bobby O'Neil Actor Maggie Lawson Liz Stoddard-Banks Actor John Benjamin Hickey Philip Stoddard Actor Christopher Sieber Simon Banks Actor Lenny Clarke Mason "Mace" O'Neil Actor Harriet Sansom Harris Audrey O'Neil Actor Paige Moss Maddy O'Neil Actor Dennis Cockrum Guest Star Jimmy Palumbo Guest Star Anne Flett-Giordano Executive Producer, Writer Chuck Ranberg Executive Producer, Writer Craig Zadan Executive Producer Neil Meron Executive Producer Andy Cadiff Director