Tim Roth Dr. Cal Lightman Actor Kelli Williams Dr. Gillian Foster Actor Monica Raymund Ria Torres Actor Brendan Hines Eli Loker Actor Mekhi Phifer FBI Agent Ben Reynolds Actor Jennifer Beals Zoe Landau Guest Star John Pyper-Ferguson Jamie Cowley Guest Star Chadwick Boseman Cabe McNeil Guest Star John Carroll Lynch Mr. Reed Guest Star James Marsters Jay Pollack Guest Star Gretchen Egolf Catherine Guest Star Colton Shires Zack Guest Star Allie Gonino Susan Guest Star Monique Edwards Mrs. McNeil Guest Star Mark Berry Mr. McNeil Guest Star Grant Alan Ouzts Wayne Guest Star Crystal Young Kate Guest Star Valerie Rose Curiel Dori Guest Star Michole Briana White Merrick Guest Star Alesa B. Gantz Agent Ferro Guest Star Hayley McFarland Emily Lightman Guest Star Samuel Baum Executive Producer Brian Grazer Executive Producer Nick Santora Writer Michael Offer Director