Rotten Tomatoes
Movies Tv shows RT App News Showtimes

Season 1 – Little Miss Innocent: Passion. Poison. Prison.

Play trailer Poster for Season 1 – Little Miss Innocent: Passion. Poison. Prison. Sep 2024 Documentary Play Trailer Watchlist
Watchlist Tomatometer Popcornmeter
Tomatometer 2 Reviews Popcornmeter Fewer than 50 Ratings
Kaitlyn Conley, a 31-year-old former receptionist, claims she has been wrongfully convicted of the 2015 killing of Mary Yoder, her former boss and the mother of her ex-boyfriend Adam.
Watch on Disney+ Stream Now

Where to Watch

Little Miss Innocent: Passion. Poison. Prison. — Season 1

Critics Reviews

View More
Stephanie Morgan Common Sense Media 10/15/2024
This series hooks viewers right away with its dramatic portrayal of a small-town murder that feels ripped from a CSI episode. Go to Full Review
Joel Keller Decider 09/26/2024
Little Miss Innocent: Passion. Poison. Prison. is a straightforward, well-paced docuseries about a case that’s anything but straightforward. Go to Full Review
Read all reviews

Audience Reviews

View More
Philip R @PhilipRoss Apr 16 It was very interesting as I was not familiar with the story. From the start, it was off putting how giddy Kaitlyn was. She portrayed herself as someone that was very excited to have the attention this show was providing her. I was surprised that she said the first year of her relationship with Adam was good but then she noted a shift with him. So she continued to stay with him and continued to pursue him? And if she was scared of him, why go to the hospital with him? It defies logic. She clearly wanted very much to be a part of his family, and went to great lengths to do so. But the most troubling aspect is how she devoted nearly all of her interview time with this show casting dispersions on the chiropractors family instead of using her time to proclaim her innocence. Again very odd. Evidence proved she purchased the drug, she confessed to wring the letter and Adam was 300 miles away? A release on a technicality does not establish innocence. And to put her parents through this.... You can see why the jury came to the verdict that they did. See more Emilio C @RT14651204 12/04/2024 In John Grisham's latest book about wrongful convictions, Framed, there is a story about a woman who contacted the police because she felt she had some information that might help them solve the crime. Instead, the police zeroed in on her as a suspect and ultimately tried and convicted her. This story has a similar trajectory. The premise of this three-part docuseries is whether Kaitlyn Conley is guilty of the crime for which she was convicted. Just as the filmmakers let viewers know from the beginning that a jury found her guilty, I will say from the beginning that I believe they convicted the wrong person. The crime involved the poisoning death of Dr. Mary Yoder from a rare medicine known as Colchicine. Once the police learn this information, they focus on finding the person who purchased it. Kaitlyn worked for Mary and her husband, Bill, at their chiropractor practice. She had also dated their son, Adam. That was her connection to the victim. This is one case where three forty-minute episodes aren't enough to get the whole picture. I wanted to see more of the trials. I wanted to hear from more of the witnesses. I wanted the filmmakers to ask more questions. If you look at this story from the outside, as most people whose only exposure to it is this documentary, it screams tunnel vision by investigators and prosecutors. Once investigators come up with a theory of the crime, they spend all of their time looking for evidence to support it. Evidence that points away from their theory is discarded or explained away. Read full review at https://everythingnonfiction.com/review-of-the-hulu-docuseries-little-miss-innocent/ See more Charlene S @whitjake 09/24/2024 The producer and director should be ashamed of themselves for not including all the evidence, ultimately making her look guilty.HERE ARE THE FACTS:Kaitlyn had been in a relationship with someone else for five months at the time that Mary died. Kaitlyn even had evidence to counter these claims, including text messages of Adam begging her to be with him again. These texts, however, were not admitted to trial. Another piece of evidence not admitted was a lie detector test taken by Kaitlyn, in which she passed. Kaitlyn claimed that she was off work in late 2014 through early 2015, when the colchicine was purchased from her work computer. Although the payroll books would have given her a solid alibi, Bill claimed that it was lost. The letter of intent to buy the poison that was supposedly written by Kaitlyn referenced biotechnology applications that Bill had used on his weed plants. They believe it is unlikely that Kaitlyn had much prior knowledge about this, and there were no searches made by her about these topics suggesting that she researched it. In the 80’s Bill used agricultural grade colchicine, the same kind used to poison Mary, to alter weed plants in order to make them grow all female plants. This would add potency to the herb produced by the plants. Despite having known about this specific drug, during the trial he said that he wasn’t aware of it. This seemed highly unlikely given that he is a physician. See more Margot 0 @MTrev 09/22/2024 I am trying to figure out why Kaitlyn would even consider participating in this biased documentary. It was so one sided. It was all about the police investigation and the prosecutor’s side of the story. I’ve seen many documentaries and I am troubled by the fact that there was absolutely no input from her defense attorneys. And the fact that the “explosive evidence” they supposedly found for the second trial was found in Adam’s computer just adds to reasonable doubt. Why would HE have all of Kaitlyn’s phones backed up on HIS computer? And if he really did have all that information WHY was he just sitting on it all that time. It’s very suspicious that it was the victim’s sister that called the police in the first place Even AFTER the family knew she’d died from poisoning THEY didn’t go to the police! And the tapes of the way the police tricked her into thinking they were investigating Adam for the murder and continued to question her while telling her that reading her the Miranda rights was just what they did to everyone who goes in that room after they’d already been questioning her for hours was devious. That girl had NO idea what they were plotting against her. But we’re supposed to believe she was a master manipulator and savvy enough to plot that murder! And why didn’t they have phone records to support the call from the woman who said she’d spoken with kaitlyn about the drug that was ordered from her company? There was just way too much reasonable doubt to find her guilty. See more Trevor R @Laaal 09/21/2024 She absolutely did it! Hope she stays in prison See more Read all reviews
Little Miss Innocent: Passion. Poison. Prison. — Season 1

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING

Episodes

Episode 1 Aired Sep 20, 2024 Why Am I Here? Kaitlyn Conley proclaims innocence and points fingers in her ex-boyfriend's mother's death. Details Episode 2 Aired Sep 20, 2024 Someone in the Circle Mary Yoder's husband Bill suddenly becomes a focus of the murder investigation. Details Episode 3 Aired Sep 20, 2024 They Took Me Down Kaitlyn Conley finds herself the main suspect in the killing of her boss Mary Yoder. Details
Born in Synanon 80% % Born in Synanon Watchlist I Love You, Now Die 97% 89% I Love You, Now Die Watchlist Pee-wee as Himself 100% 92% Pee-wee as Himself Watchlist TRAILER for Pee-wee as Himself Hollywood Black 88% % Hollywood Black Watchlist Philly D.A. 92% 86% Philly D.A. Watchlist Discover more movies and TV shows. View More

Season Info

Network
Hulu
Genre
Documentary
Original Language
English
Release Date
Sep 20, 2024