Monica Beletsky Creator, Executive Producer Tobias Menzies Edwin Stanton Actor Anthony Boyle John Wilkes Booth Actor Lovie Simone Mary Simms Actor Will Harrison David Herold Actor Brandon Flynn Eddie Stanton Jr. Actor Patton Oswalt Detective Lafayette Baker Actor Matt Walsh Dr. Samuel Mudd Actor Hamish Linklater Abraham Lincoln Actor Carl Franklin Executive Producer, Director Michael Rotenberg Executive Producer Richard Abate Executive Producer Frank Smith Executive Producer Naia Cucukov Executive Producer Layne P. Eskridge Executive Producer James Swanson Executive Producer