Bryan Greenberg Nick Garrett Actor Laura Prepon Hannah Daniels Actor Geoff Stults Eddie Latekka Actor Brad William Henke Owen Rowan Actor Jay Paulson Physical Phil Actor Tom Berenger Bob "The Commander" Garrett Actor Evan Jones Ikey Actor Slade Pearce Sam Daniels Actor Warren Christie Ray "Big Cat" Cataldo Actor Odette Annable Aubrey Actor Rebecca Field Janet "The Planet" Meadows Actor Lindy Booth Pizza Girl Actor Jonathan Murphy Ronnie Garrett Guest Star Christopher Eric Tschupp Matthew Lauche Guest Star Diego Garcia Mook 1 Guest Star Sam Stefamski Mook 2 Guest Star Keeshan Giles Mook 3 Guest Star James Keane Sully Guest Star J.R. Nutt Granger Guest Star Michael Cornacchia Carter Bump Guest Star Katelin Chesna Karen Guest Star John Asher Ronald Buckman Guest Star Gary Fleder Executive Producer Scott Rosenberg Executive Producer Josh Appelbaum Executive Producer Andre Nemec Executive Producer Bryan Oh Writer Andrew Bernstein Director