Amber Asay Contestant Andrea Hilderbrand Contestant Angie Esparza Contestant Brian Kahrs Contestant Corey Johnson Contestant Dawn Nelson Contestant Javier Colón Contestant Jill Ashock Contestant Joel Hungate Contestant Jordan Williams Contestant Justin Court Contestant Lee Ettinger Contestant Nick Radner Contestant Paul Preece Contestant Seth Lueker Contestant Timothy Spears Contestant Jason Bateman Executive Producer Michael Costigan Executive Producer Emma Ho Executive Producer Grant Kahler Executive Producer Mike Odair Executive Producer