Adam Scott Henry Pollard Actor Ken Marino Ron Donald Actor Megan Mullally Lydia Dunfree Actor Ryan Hansen Kyle Bradway Actor Martin Starr Roman Debeers Actor Lizzy Caplan Casey Klein Actor June Diane Raphael Danielle Lugozshe Guest Star Aviva Mandy Guest Star Andrea Savage Annie LeGros Guest Star Dave Allen AF Gordon Theodore Guest Star Michael Hitchcock Bolus Lugozshe Guest Star Ian Roberts Jeff Guest Star Joey Lauren Adams Diandra Stiltskin Guest Star Sarah Burns Donna Mullens Guest Star Michael Kostroff Jeff Gold Guest Star Jennifer Wenger Stacy Guest Star Matt Riedy Guy Guest Star René Ashton Claire the Clown Guest Star Jillian Armenante Mona Guest Star Scott Michael Morgan Scruffy Man Guest Star Bryan Gordon Director David Wain Director