Jim Caviezel John Reese Actor Michael Emerson Harold Finch Actor Taraji P. Henson Joss Carter Actor Kevin Chapman Lionel Fusco Actor Brennan Brown Special Agent Nicholas Donnelly Guest Star Creighton James Wayne F. Packer Guest Star James Knight Brian Kelly Guest Star Brendan Griffin Charles MacAvoy Guest Star Luke Kleintank Caleb Phipps Guest Star Luke Kirby Chris Beckner Guest Star Mary B. McCann Lori Phipps Guest Star Hassan Johnson Lorenzo Guest Star Ananias Dixon Diego Velasquez Guest Star Susan Blackwell Principal Lawton Guest Star Stevie Steel Julia Franklin Guest Star Malika Samuel Lily Williams Guest Star James Colby Officer Murphy Guest Star Frank Frankson Howard Glazer Guest Star John Sharian Warden Hutchins Guest Star Michael Heckler Tall Guy Guest Star David Fierro Stocky Guy Guest Star Jeff Woodman FBI Tech Guest Star J.J. Abrams Executive Producer Bryan Burk Executive Producer Jonathan Nolan Executive Producer David Semel Executive Producer Greg Plageman Executive Producer Dan Dietz Writer Richard J. Lewis Director