Jake Gyllenhaal Rusty Sabich Actor, Executive Producer Ruth Negga Barbara Sabich Actor Bill Camp Raymond Horgan Actor Elizabeth Marvel Lorraine Horgan Actor Peter Sarsgaard Tommy Molto Actor O.T. Fagbenle Nico Della Guardia Actor Renate Reinsve Carolyn Polhemus Actor Tate Birchmore Michael Caldwell Actor David E. Kelley Executive Producer, Writer J.J. Abrams Executive Producer Anne Sewitsky Executive Producer Dustin Thomason Executive Producer Sharr White Writer