Cinco Paul Creator, Executive Producer Ken Daurio Creator Cecily Strong Melissa Gimble Actor Keegan-Michael Key Josh Skinner Actor Dove Cameron Betsy McDonough, Jenny Banks Actor Jaime Camil Doc Lopez, Sergeant Rivera Actor Kristin Chenoweth Margaret, Mildred Layton, Miss Coldwell Actor Alan Cumming Mayor Aloysius Menlove, Dooley Flint Actor Ariana DeBose Emma Tate, Emcee Actor Ann Harada Florence Menlove, Madam Frau Actor Jane Krakowski Countess von Blerkom, Bobbie Flanagan Actor Patrick Page Octavius Kratt Actor Martin Short Leprechaun Actor Aaron Tveit Danny Bailey, Topher Actor Tituss Burgess Narrator Actor Fred Armisen Reverend Layton Actor Lorne Michaels Executive Producer Barry Sonnenfeld Executive Producer Andrew Singer Executive in Charge of Production