David Boreanaz Jason Hayes Actor Max Thieriot Clay Spenser Actor Neil Brown Jr. Ray Perry Actor A.J. Buckley Sonny Quinn Actor Toni Trucks Lisa Davis Actor Jessica Paré Mandy Ellis Actor Judd Lormand Lieutenant Commander Eric Blackburn Actor Tyler Grey Trent Guest Star Alona Tal Stella Guest Star Parisa Fakhri Naima Guest Star Kerri Medders Emma Hayes Guest Star Kaliayh Rhambo Jameelah Guest Star José Miguel Pérez Dr. Sullivan Guest Star Peter Jessop Commander Shaw Guest Star Ammon Jacob Ford Mikey Hayes Guest Star Michael McGrady Harrington Guest Star C. Thomas Howell Ash Spencer Guest Star Kristy Swanson Julia Guest Star Chuck Kelley Bartender Guest Star Atul Singh Batra Guest Star Catherine Dent Liddy Breen Guest Star Lynn Chen Patty Watson Guest Star Kenneth Meseroll Priest Guest Star Laura Gardner Doris Sawyer Guest Star Benjamin Cavell Executive Producer Ed Redlich Executive Producer Christopher Chulack Executive Producer, Director Sarah Timberman Executive Producer Carl Beverly Executive Producer John Glenn Writer Spencer Hudnut Writer