Supergirl: Season 4 Episode 5 Reviews
![]() | Sarah Fields Tell-Tale TV | November 13, 2018 The episode does an excellent job of pulling together various plots in a way that feels cohesive and moves the overarching story forward. Full Review | Original Score: 4/5 | ||
| Amelia Emberwing Birth.Movies.Death. | November 12, 2018 Nia Nal has been a joy to watch. Nia adds an earnestness to the series that it lost for a brief time... | ||
| Ben Rolph TheDCTVshow | November 12, 2018 I felt like I was actually watching Supergirl again, the one I've always loved. Full Review | Original Score: 5/5 | ||
![]() | Lizzy Buczak TV Fanatic | November 12, 2018 Though there are enjoyable moments sprinkled throughout Supergirl Season 4, overall, I'm just not connecting with the main storyline.There were even moments where I started zoning out. Full Review | Original Score: 2.6/5 | ||
![]() | Amy Woolsey Culturess | November 12, 2018 Normally, a plot about Kara doing journalism would make me nervous; as I've noted probably too many times, Supergirl's portrayal of the media plays rather fast and loose with reality. | ||
| Meagan Damore CBR | November 12, 2018 J'onn made his first steps towards becoming an alien detective. | ||
![]() | Andy Swift TV Line | November 12, 2018 Frankly, I think she went too far by ending her celebratory brunch with a toast "to health, happiness and basking in the sunshine." On a TV show, that's straight-up tempting fate. | ||
| Caroline Siede AV Club | Top Critic | November 12, 2018 Parasite Lost" somehow has way too much going on, yet also a lot of time to fill. It's not a bad episode, per se, but it is a bit of a weird one. Full Review | Original Score: B | |
![]() | Delia Harrington Den of Geek | November 12, 2018 Ironically, Supergirl more successfully sidelined its hero this week than last, when she was in a full-body suit and was physically on the brink of death. Full Review | Original Score: 3/5 | ||
![]() | Sara Netzley Entertainment Weekly | Top Critic | November 12, 2018 The transformation is stunning, and Sam Witwer is killing it as one of the scariest CW superhero villains in a long, long time. He's glib and golden and furiously angry, and it's hypnotic to watch. Full Review | Original Score: A- |