Justin Spitzer Creator, Executive Producer Ben Feldman Jonah Actor Mark McKinney Glenn Actor Lauren Ash Dina Actor Colton Dunn Garrett Actor Nichole Sakura Cheyenne Actor Nico Santos Mateo Actor America Ferrera Amy Guest Star Jon Barinholtz Marcus Guest Star Maria Thayer Hannah Guest Star Irene White Carol Guest Star Kelly Schumann Justine Guest Star Carla Renata Janet Guest Star Franchesca Ramsey Nia Guest Star Kelen Coleman Megan Guest Star Ashley Marie Jones Dido Guest Star Rasha Goel Reporter Guest Star Josh Sussman Puppet Mike Guest Star Dan Lippert Cookie Customer Guest Star Ernie Reyes Jr. Candle Customer Guest Star Harrison Cone Bax Guest Star Bonnie Kolber Curious Customer Guest Star David Bernad Executive Producer Ruben Fleischer Executive Producer Gabe Miller Executive Producer Jonathan Green Executive Producer Jackie Clarke Executive Producer Victor Nelli Jr. Director Owen Ellickson Writer Laura McCreary Writer