Alison Sweeney Host Gail Lee Contestant Lauren Lee Contestant Mark Cornelison Contestant Isaac "Chism" Cornelison Contestant Kim Stone Contestant Megan Stone Contestant Nancy Rajala Contestant Cassandra Sturos Contestant Conda Britt Contestant Jeremy Britt Contestant Adrian Dortch Contestant Daphne Dortch Contestant Joe Messina Contestant Mike Messina Contestant Allen "Buddy" Shuh Contestant Ben Shuh Contestant Christine Pickler Contestant Roy Pickler Contestant Emily Joy Contestant Kim Neilsen Contestant Rebecca "Becky" Comet Guest Star Antone Davis Guest Star Vencent "Vinny" Hickerson Guest Star Ben Silverman Executive Producer David Broome Executive Producer J.D. Roth Executive Producer John Foy Executive Producer Todd Nelson Executive Producer Todd Lubin Executive Producer Alex Katz Executive Producer