Justin Theroux Kevin Garvey Actor Amy Brenneman Laurie Garvey Actor Christopher Eccleston Matt Jamison Actor Liv Tyler Meg Abbott Actor Chris Zylka Tom Garvey Actor Margaret Qualley Jill Garvey Actor Carrie Coon Nora Durst Actor Emily Meade Aimee Actor Amanda Warren Lucy Warburton Actor Ann Dowd Patti Levin Actor Michael Gaston Dean Actor Max Carver Adam Frost Actor Charlie Carver Scott Frost Actor Annie Q. Riegel Christine Actor Brad Leland Congressman Witten Guest Star Paterson Joseph Wayne Gilchrest Guest Star Peter Berg Pete Guest Star, Executive Producer, Director Sydni Beaudoin Black Girl Guest Star Catherine Curtin Mrs. Tunney Guest Star Michael Eric Dyson Male Pundit Guest Star Jim C. Ferris Council Member Guest Star Jack Ferry Older Cop Guest Star Danny Flaherty Max Guest Star Natalie Gold Sam's Mother Guest Star Frank Harts Officer Dennis Luckey Guest Star Casey Jordan Female Pundit Guest Star Bill Heck Darren Guest Star Marceline Hugot Gladys Guest Star Edward James Hyland Senator From Texas Guest Star Lola Kirke Hailey Guest Star Adam LeFevre Mike the Bartender Guest Star Pedro Saint Morillo Tattooed Kid Guest Star Andrea Navedo Field Hockey Coach Guest Star Michael Nostrand Dr. Denziger Guest Star Jake Robinson Nick Guest Star Christina Saragaglia Girl With Piercings Guest Star I.N. Sierros Doug (Fire Chief) Guest Star Noah Unger Little Boy Guest Star Madison Zamor Girl Scout No. 1 Guest Star Daniel Alain Birch Young Dorfman Guest Star Lyndsey Bloise Girl Scout No. 5 Guest Star Linwood Brown Science Teacher Guest Star Dean Curtis Elvis Guest Star Rita Duran Townsperson Guest Star Marcos A. Gonzalez Guilty Remnant Guest Star Heather Connolly Granger Partygoer Guest Star Daniel Grote Party Bong Guy Guest Star Cal Koury Baker Brother Guest Star Chris Nunez Bathtub Tweeker Guest Star Rajeev Pahuja Dry Cleaner Employee Guest Star Laura Rothschild Townsperson Guest Star Stuart Schnitzer Core Guilty Remnant Guest Star Kimi Valdivia Girl With Missing Sign Guest Star Damon Lindelof Executive Producer, Writer Tom Perrotta Executive Producer, Writer Sarah Aubrey Executive Producer