Mary-Ellis Bunim Creator T.J. Lavin Host Alyssa Lopez Contestant Angela Rummans Contestant Azah Awasum Contestant Ben Driebergen Contestant Cashay Proudfoot Contestant Cashel Barnett Contestant Cayla Platt Contestant Cely Vazquez Contestant Danny McCray Contestant David Alexander Contestant Derek Xiao Contestant Desi Williams Contestant Domenick Abbate Contestant Enzo Palumbo Contestant James Wallington Contestant Javonny Vega Contestant Justine Ndiba Contestant Kyland Young Contestant Kyra Green Contestant Leo Temory Contestant Melvin "Cinco" Holland Jr. Contestant Sarah Lacina Contestant Shantel Smith Contestant Shannon St. Clair Contestant Latasha "Tasha" Fox Contestant Tiffany Mitchell Contestant Tyson Apostol Contestant Xavier Prather Contestant Fred Birckhead Executive Producer