Dallas Jenkins Creator, Writer, Director Jonathan Roumie Jesus Actor Shahar Isaac Simon Peter Actor Elizabeth Tabish Mary Magdalene Actor Paras Patel Matthew Actor Noah James Andrew Actor Nick Shakoour Zebedee Actor George H. Xanthis John Actor Lara Silva Eden Actor Yoshi Barrigas Philip Guest Star Shaan Sharma Shmuel Guest Star Kirk B.R. Wooler Gaius Guest Star Allesandro Colla Jairus Guest Star Elijah Alexander Atticus Guest Alaa Safi Simon Z Guest Star Zhaleh Vossough Veronica Guest Star Ryan Swanson Writer Tyler Thompson Writer