Joan Allen Claire Actor Alison Pill Willa Actor Margot Bingham Detective Nina Meyer Actor Zach Gilford Danny Actor Liam James Adam Actor Floriana Lima Bridey Actor Madeleine Arthur Young Willa Actor Rarmian Newton Young Danny Actor Rupert Graves John Warren Actor Andrew McCarthy Hank Actor Michael Esper Pock-Marked Man Guest Star Hampton Fluker Josh Langham Guest Star Felix Solis Gus Flores Guest Star Alexa Steele Young Bridey Cruz Guest Star Ian Quinlan Paul Guest Star Jenna Bans Executive Producer, Writer Todd Lieberman Executive Producer David Hoberman Executive Producer Laurie Zaks Executive Producer Paul McGuigan Director