Lee Eisenberg Creator, Executive Producer Elan Gale Creator, Executive Producer Daniel Tosh Host, Executive Producer Tayshia Adams Contestant Joe Amabile Contestant Kristen Doute Contestant Justin Johnson Contestant Reza Farahan Contestant C.J. Franco Contestant Wendell Holland Contestant Teck Holmes Contestant Paola Mayfield Contestant Da'Vonne Rogers Contestant Joey Sasso Contestant Jason Smith Contestant Lauren Speed Contestant Jill Zarin Contestant Bill Dixon Executive Producer Anthony Anderson Executive Producer Michael Friedman Executive Producer Anthony Anderson Executive Producer Isabel San Vargas Executive Producer Howard T. Owens Executive Producer Ben Silverman Executive Producer Howard Owens Executive Producer Audrey E. Smith Executive Producer Matthew M. Welty Executive Producer Michael Shea Director