Mindy Kaling Mindy Actor, Executive Producer Chris Messina Danny Actor Zoe Jarman Betsy Actor Ed Weeks Jeremy Actor Ike Barinholtz Morgan Actor Adam Pally Peter Actor Beth Grant Beverly Actor Kevin Smith Guest Star Chloë Sevigny Guest Star Glenn Howerton Guest Star Mark Duplass Guest Star Ben Feldman Guest Star Amy Vorpahl Guest Star Tarina Pouncy Guest Star Donnell Turner Guest Star Nanci Filipelli Guest Star Xosha Roquemore Guest Star Jush Allen Guest Star Michael Benzaia Guest Star Jennifer Daley Guest Star Margarita Rozenbaoum Guest Star Heather Ryan Guest Star James Skinner Guest Star Nikki Wright Guest Star Howard Klein Executive Producer Matt Warburton Executive Producer Michael Alan Spiller Executive Producer Jack Burditt Executive Producer