Rebecca Romijn Host Jerry O'Connell Host Ted Lange Guest Star Alisa Shah Contestant Brett De Laura Contestant Brooke White Contestant Daniel Cooper Contestant Emily Stone Contestant Forrest Jones Contestant Jordan Malabanan Contestant Marty Hassett Contestant Michael Gonzalez Contestant Nathan Kroger Contestant Nicole Wong Contestant Shea-Lynn Noyes Contestant Paolo Arrigo Self Ezra Freeman Self Matt Mitcham Self Chris Culvenor Executive Producer Paul Franklin Executive Producer Wes Dening Executive Producer Jay Bienstock Executive Producer